disbelief
I'll go to the foot of our stairs
strike me up a gum tree
holy cats
astonishing
stound
perplexed
stuck
oh, my stars and garters
confounded
the mind boggles
God preserve us
stupefaction
popeyed
puzzly
crikey
masker
holy
perplexing
wildering
nubilous
bewilderedly
bewilderment
wowie zowie
unastonishable
puzzlingly
left-handed
I'll be dipped in shit
Jerusalem crickets
open-mouthed
stagger
uneven
with one's jaw in one's lap
swallow
fugg
mask
gape
maffled
weirdling
problem
confusement
head-scratching
dudder
mazy
on a wonder
amazing
bollix
outlandish
oddity
unsurely
unfamiliar
janky
confuzzlement
enigmatic
great Caesar's ghost
at sea
puzzledly
agoggle
stunning
bemaze
unusuality
bifarious
enigmalike
wide-eyed
oddish
feel
confuzzle
perplexedly
baffound
of all things
I see, said the blind man
consarn
runish
phantom
of all places
astonished
confuzzled
gape-mouthed
puzzlement
spreckled
peppered
equivocally
staggered
thrown
bewigged
turbid
knocked over with a feather
unheimlich
all sixes and nines
at sixes and sevens
bizarrerie
hurry-skurry
weird
puzzle
problematical
confusable