never-was
never-would-be
dead-ender
noncontender
always a bridesmaid, never a bride
nonaspiring
nonpopularity
never-wozzer
might-have-been
unpopular
nonadmirer
nonplanner
undercelebrated
legend in one's own lunchtime
nonsuperstar
a rolling stone gathers no moss
shortcomer
unrenown
nonaficionado
no-hoper
unhopeful
nonchampion
player hater
underknown
sadfuck
famelessness
nonenthusiast
nonstardom
nonreviewer
nearly man
nonreputable
nonvisionary
lacker
nonprestige
nonrival
successlessness
catch-allism
lackluster
antiprogressist
defaulter
jack of all trades, master of none
talentlessness
antiprogressionist
noncompetitor
shit
poorly
antiprogressive
unidolized
born loser
untalented